Montana

July 26, 2011

Aluminum Bat Wrongful Death Verdict Affirmed

The Montana Supreme Court affirmed an $850,000 award to the parents of a baseball player who tragically died after being struck by a ball hit with an aluminum baseball bat.

If your kids are playing baseball – particularly if they are pitching – you have thought about these facts. An 18-year-old boy is pitching in an American Legion baseball game and gets hit in the head. Just an awful case that makes you question whether or not your kids should be playing any sport. There is no completely safe game.

February 24, 2011

Wrongful Death Malpractice Verdict in Montana

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

A Montana jury awarded $1.7 million in a wrongful death misdiagnosis case. Plaintiffs’ medical malpractice lawsuit alleged that a Billings internal medicine doctor misdiagnosed their husband/father’s heart valve condition. Plaintiffs claimed – and the jury agreed – that the doctor should have diagnosed the condition and referred the man to a specialist. The man died a year after seeing the doctor. Plaintiffs’ theory of the case was that had the diagnosis been made in a timely fashion as the ordinary, prudent doctor would have done, the death could have been avoided with a heart valve transplant.

I don’t know about the nuance of facts. That’s a tough claim, the “could have gotten a heart valve transplant” case. But plaintiffs’ malpractice lawyers made the claim stick.

February 18, 2011

Medical Malpractice in Montana | What Is the Law?

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

Medical malpractice is a hot issue in Montana as its legislature considers various malpractice related bills.

What struck me in this article is this quote:

Robert Stears, a diagnostic radiologist from Billings, said he gets calls from doctors far too often that end with “Bob I’m sorry I had to order this test. I know it’s going to be normal, but you know how it is.”

October 22, 2009

Zometa Lawsuits

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

A Montana jury has awarded $3.2 million to a woman attributing degenerative jaw problems after taking to bone-strengthening drug Zometa. In the lawsuit against Novartis Pharmaceuticals, the Plaintiff alleged Novartis failed to warn that Zometa could cause osteonecrosis.

This is a big victory for plaintiffs in the Zometa lawsuits.

September 15, 2009

Doctor Settles Civil Rights Lawsuit in Montana

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

Missoula County agreed to pay a doctor $5,000 to settle his civil rights complaint after he was refused medical treatment while in jail for obstructing his efforts to provide care to a suicidal woman. After the doctor was arrested for ignoring police commands to withdraw while attempting to aid an armed suicidal woman (which sounds completely insane to me), he experienced chest pains and requested an EKG because of his history of heart problems. As part of the settlement with Missoula County, the municipality will also review the doctor’s concerns regarding policies for medical treatment for inmates.

December 10, 2008

Loser Pays System

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

A report released last week by the Manhattan Institute — “Greater Justice, Lower Cost: How a ‘Loser Pays’ Rule Would Improve the American Legal System” — says making personal injury lawsuit losers pay the winner’s legal expenses would improve the fairness of our legal system.

“The integrity of our legal system is under assault. Establishing loser-pays rules and other tort reforms can help restore citizens’ faith in the bedrock of society — justice, fairness, and the rule of law,” former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani wrote in the preface to the report. (With the election over, Giuliani is apparently capable of complete sentences that do not contain 9/11. I am a little surprised.)
I have not given the issue any thought. I think the problem is that it presents an intimidating bar for Plaintiffs who have been the victim of someone else’s negligence in a case that is not clear cut. Do we want to discourage those suits? —–

April 18, 2008

$5.3 Million First Party Bad Faith Verdict in Missoula, Montana

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

A U.S. District court jury in Missoula, Montana awarded a Bigfork doctoral student $5.3 million, finding Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company acted in bad faith. This verdict, which included $3.5 million in punitive damages, is the largest bad-faith insurance verdict in Montana history.

Plaintiff, a 32-year-old salmon ecologist, suffered brain injuries in a head-on collision. Her insurance policy included $1.5 million in uninsured motorist benefits.

Why did the jury find bad faith in Fireman’s Fund’s refusal to pay? Well, in the four years after Fireman’s Insurance received notice of plaintiff’s, it did virtually no investigation at all. Fireman’s Fun collected one lousy page of her medical records, never sought a statement from the Plaintiff, or requested an IME or did anything to support their denial.

April 8, 2008

$1.2 Million Jury Award to Railway Worker

by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

A Billings, Montana jury awarded $1.2 million dollars on Friday to a former BNSF Railway employee, who suffered a spinal injury two years ago. The jury found that BNSF had violated the Locomotive Inspection Act. The award was $840,000 in lost wages and $360,000 for pain and suffering.

Fredric A. Bremseth, a Denver lawyer who handles a lot of railroad cases apparently, represented the Plaintiff. Michelle Friend, a Billings, Montana lawyer, represented the railroad.